Another Chance for The Grand Tour with Fresh Hosts – Because Exceptional Things Must Live On

As per the Broadcast report, Studio Lambert has received a contract to produce a new iteration of the series, though specific details remain scant. It remains uncertain whether the new version of The Grand Tour would feature three hosts, adhere to the original studio setup, or retain the recent emphasis on special episodes alone. Nevertheless, whoever clinches the role, in whatever capacity, will face significant challenges.

Clarkson, Hammond, and May have encountered obstacles in recent years, largely due to controversies involving the former. The trio left hosting Top Gear on the BBC after Clarkson assaulted a producer, alongside his history of provocative public remarks. Despite the challenges, the chemistry among the three hosts is nearly irreplaceable. The BBC experimented with various hosting combinations without replicating the original trio’s dynamic successfully. The essence of Top Gear was not merely about discussing cars; it centered on Clarkson, Hammond, and May engaging in automotive banter, a resonance difficult to recreate. Although The Grand Tour may not have matched the popularity or quality of prime Top Gear, stepping into the shoes of that iconic trio and achieving success will be an arduous task.

Replacing the legendary hosts is not the sole challenge. What new experiences could the fresh hosts embark upon that the prior trio had not ventured into? The scarcity of innovative ideas contributed to Clarkson and Co.’s decision to conclude their automotive ventures. Clarkson conveyed to The Sunday Times in January, “I’ve broken automotive frontiers more than anyone and explored the northern expanse extensively. We’ve exhausted all conceivable vehicular exploits. When brainstorming future plans, the team felt at a loss for fresh avenues.”

This does not imply waning interest in cars or the automotive industry; on the contrary, the sector remains captivating, perhaps more so than ever. Yet, television might not be the ideal platform. Clarkson reflected, “James May asserts that contemporary mobility innovations are more intriguing than ever, and he’s likely correct. However, I contend that it doesn’t translate as compelling television. An electric car parallels a chest freezer or a microwave oven. Absent is the allure and thrill. Coming up this week on Top Chest Freezer! It appears more suited to print media.”

While exceptional automotive television is still conceivable, reviving The Grand Tour with new hosts may not be the optimal approach. A new show with a distinct name, hosts, concepts, and format might be necessary for a successful revival. However, as a society that clings to venerable traditions, and with Amazon intent on exploiting The Grand Tour to its fullest extent, one hopes any prospective hosts are afforded ample time to cultivate the camaraderie that defined the original trio.

Insights to share? Send them to tips@thedrive.com